The death of an innocent Brazilian man shot by marksmen of Scotland
Yard's ant-terrorism squad in the summer of 2005 resulted from "very
serious but avoidable mistakes," an independent report said Thursday.
Jean Charles de Menezes, who was shot seven times in the head by
anti-terrorist officers who mistook him for a suicide bomber, fell
victim to a series of failures in communication, planning and execution
of the police operation, the report by the Independent Police
Complaints Commission (IPCC) said.
De Menezes, 27, was shot on July 22, 2005, a day after police in
London foiled an attempted second suicide bombing on the transport
network, following the major attack of July 7, in which 52 people died
and more than 700 were injured.
The Brazilian died after being followed by plain-cloths officers
who chased him on to an Underground train at Stockwell Tube station in
south London on the morning of July 22.
In its report, the IPCC said that police radios used on the day
failed to work underground, and there was a "lack of clarity over
language used by firearms officers and their superiors to sanction the
shooting."
The police watchdog, which made 16 recommendations, demanded a
"wider public debate and understanding of the tactical options for
combating the threat from suicide bombers."
But in a passage likely to damage further the standing of Ian
Blair, head of Scotland Yard, the IPCC said the police commissioner had
personally been responsible for "delaying an independent investigation"
into the shooting.
Blair, 54, who is under pressure to resign over the case, Thursday
again expressed his "deep personal regret" for the "tragic" shooting of
de Menezes, but made clear that he intended to stay in his post as
Britain's most senior policeman.
"Our overall record is good. All the officers involved have my full
support," he said. Blair again stressed the "difficult circumstances"
in which the police were operating as London faced an "unprecedented
threat" from terrorism.
Blair said London police had been called to 10,000 potential
firearms incidents over that last 12 months, and fired "only three
times."
While both opposition parties, the Conservatives and the Liberal
Democrats, have called for Blair to step down, the Labour government of
Prime Minister Gordon Brown has repeatedly expressed "full confidence"
in the police chief.
The family of de Menezes welcomed the report, but said they would
continue their efforts to achieve "justice" as no individual had so far
been held to account for the shooting.
Spokeswoman Yasmin Khan said the report was "another damning
indictment of the Metropolitan Police," while Blair's position had
become "untenable."
The family's lawyer, Harriet Wistrich, said they would take the
case to the European Court for Human Rights over "fundamental issues
about the accountability of police officers who kill people."
Within hours of the shooting, Blair told a 2005 news conference:
"This shooting is directly linked to the anti-terrorist operation."
Blair has said that he left his Scotland Yard offices late on the
night of the shooting and was not told "until the next day" that an
innocent man had been killed.
The IPCC, which demanded a public debate over the "policy to shoot
suspected suicide bombers," said in its report: "The commissioner
attempted to prevent us carrying out an investigation."
The victim's family described that statement as "shocking new evidence."