“SiCKO”: not a Fair Movie
“SiCKO”: not a Fair Movie
Michael Moore’s controversial latest documentary about the United States’ health care system has been recently categorized as a personal battle of the filmmaker against his country. “SiCKO” does not present the American health care system with its good and bad parts, it focuses only on the bad aspects of it; that is why Moore’s documentary seems to be less than an objective documentary, and more of a personal revolt.

Whether he is right to be revolted, this is once again a personal issue, but making a movie featuring personal frustrations, that’s not OK. In fact, Moore’s critics haven’t said that he is completely wrong. It’s only that he fails to provide the documentary with a part where the health care system’s representatives could try to defend it, or just to speak about the good parts of the American service.

The popular filmmaker used “SiCKO” to launch only serious accusations on the American health care system, which involves doctors, hospitals, drug makers and so on. The documentary features common American people that are talking about their sad experiences related to the health care system, but not even a single fellow defending the system. Doctors, drug makers and hospital managers are accused of putting their own greedy interests above their patients’, while a number of about 50 million people are said not to afford the health insurance service.

On the other hand, Michael Moore is praising through his movie other countries’ health care systems. Canada, France, Britain and even Cuba are on this list, although the director doesn’t tell about any ranking: with France featuring the most secure health care system, all the other countries are not even in the first position of this ranking (Cuba, for example is ranked 39th, below the United States).

As critics say, “SiCKO” could have been quite a good documentary on this issue, if Moore had been wise enough to let the both sides to express their problems and concerns. But the director chose to exaggerate only the bad parts of the story.




© 2007 - 2008 - eNews 2.0 All Rights Reserved
 
 
You can't handle the Truth
By Mikey, (2008-06-18 05:13)
As Americans, we have a hard time looking at the Truth, even when it stares us in the face. The shame of it all, not only do these countries have free health care for everyone, they also send their kids to higher education for free... I know they pay taxes for it, but some pay less than we do and some pay a little more. But who cares, they care more for their citizens than we do. Why, because their citizens demand it. It is like Michigan asking for more in state income taxes when a state like Tennessee doesn't even have an income tax. It's the same difference but these are other countries that are better than we are.....
Rank?
By Karey, (2008-02-21 05:04)
"the director doesn’t tell about any ranking: with France featuring the most secure health care system, all the other countries are not even in the first position of this ranking (Cuba, for example is ranked 39th, below the United States)."

Can you cite a source for this ranking? Since its not Moore obviously?
Since When Do They Offer Time for Opposing Views
By TheRagingModerate, (2008-02-19 01:18)
Moore should start offering the HMOs time during his movies to defend themselves when they start letting average people tell their stories in HMO-paid advertising and lobbying efforts.

My God, eNews, what kind of twisted, pro-corporate worldview do you have that this omission by Moore seems unfair? It's his movie. He was using it to tell a story that NEVER EVER gets fair airtime in this country. Why the hell should he give the HMOs and Big Pharma free airtime to promote their agendas and tell their "side of the story" when, apart from rare films like Sicko, theirs is the ONLY side of the story that EVER gets told? The goal here is to wake people up to the fact that we have a major problem with healthcare in this country. It's not to reinforce the mistaken belief in the minds of the electorate that, "There are two sides to every story and, oh well, this is just another area that we should not concern ourselves with and just let the politicians and the business people handle it because it's far too complex for us to form a meaningful opinion about it." That's their game: Make us all believe that the issue (in this case, whether a new model for healthcare is needed) has two incredbly complex, but ultimately equal, sides to it -- even when, as here, that's simply not the case. Sometimes there really is a right side of a debate and a wrong side, and I thank Michael Moore for unapologetically arguing for the right side in this debate on the need for wholesale reformation of our healthcare system.
well put RagingModerate
By Steven, (2008-06-18 15:37)
I could not have said it better either.
well put RagingModerate,
By TheRagingH.O., (2008-06-18 06:50)
I couldn't have said it better.
?
By Norm, (2008-02-07 20:12)
So how is this different from every other movie this slob has made?
Sick USA
By Milesinnz, (2008-01-06 19:07)
So long as those negative stories portrayed in this documentary are genuine, which I am sure they are, it is of little relevance that there is a “good” side to the USA health system. A country should be judged by how it looks after its more vulnerable members of it's society, and if SICKO is anything to go by, the USA is as sick society.
"It's Just The United States"
By Chunkzilla76, (2007-12-30 17:24)
Of course the article about Sicko is written to evoke a response from the readers. What the movie should have done is proven to the American public our health care system needs to be shut down just like any other business, institution or health risk posed to the public. Isn't that what the health department does? But no! Even after the MD from Humana admitted what she had done was "a health risk," America just sits back for the entertainment it is and does nothing. The admission on this MD's part, supporting information from the film should have put a mob crowd on the health care system to stop this practice immediately. But much like 911, as long as it's a good watch, why look any furhther into the possibility the USA caused it. Pure and simple, this nation of ours is corrupt, deliberate and the people don't care. We deserve everything we get!
Not fair?
By Richard, (2007-12-28 16:29)
Why the attackers have to be fair, when the defenders are bigger, richer and always unfair?
Power is Truth
By Peter Verkooijen, (2008-02-11 05:10)
Sicko is a socialist propaganda movie. Socialists don't believe in facts or truth, they believe that ideology colors everything and that they can change the world by changing the language and the perception of facts. The bigger the lie, the more it will be believed. Power is Truth.
Unfair?!, Socialist propaganda? Oh please!
By RebelWITHacause, (2008-03-17 05:31)
It is truly ironic that you would be the first person exercising your 1st amendment right to bitch and moan if you were in a similar position as any of the beleaguered crew patients shown in this documentary.
Micheal more simply takes the system to task, in the hope that it will at least think twice before one day turn around and biting any one else in the butt, The system is a Fraud and change is INEVITABLE, Why do you think all the candidates for the next presidential election are trying to ride this sucker all the way to the white house , except McCain of course he's running on the "Moore War" ticket, (Pun most definitely intended)Democracy is a trip inst it?.
If you cant see that the changes proposed in this movie are for the COMMON GOOD then you are either very selfish or not very bright. (Or perhaps like a good capitalist you are simply up to your eyeballs in Healthcare stocks)which would make you both selfish and greedy.
 
 
Watch Out for Mosquitoes! Warning Isn’t OverWatch Out for Mosquitoes! Warning Isn’t Over
Decline in West Nile infections is over and the KPCC wants to know what can happen if a healthy person contracts the illness. Jack Raney of Upland contacted the disease...

Watch Out for Mosquitoes! Warning Isn’t Over
 

dotclear
dotclear